Which is Better - Home Equity Loan Or a No Cash Out Refinance?

Every mortgage or refinance needs a target;mortgage?
something larger we're trying to accomplish beyondJust focusing on the mortgage is fine-who doesn't
just buying/refinancing a home or investment property.want a lower home payment. But when we look at
The best loan isn't always the loan with the lowestthe mortgage in context of the overall family
rate, but the loan that helps you move forwardexpenses we are really doing is improving your overall
financially.financial plan. This is what a financial planner truly
Here are a few "Refinance Rules" you may want toneeds to do. And all financial planning begins on the
consider.mortgage level. Because when you are out of debt
These are rules aren't strict-rather they are just likeyou have more money to save, to invest, to build
the sites on a rifle...they help everyone get a focus.towards retirement.
Because a mortgage should not be an end in and ofAnd it all this begins on the mortgage level.
itself, but a means to a bigger end.What's your current refinance goal? Maybe your
Top Refinance Rules...situation might be "Hey Mr. Mortgage guy, what loan do
#1) Eliminating Consumer Debt: (Non-tax deductible)you suggest that will help me retire at age 55."
#2) Have a Savings Cushion: Ideally 3-6 months in aLet's talk about Home Equity Loans: We recently
liquid interest-bearing account.helped a client get out of debt with a home equity loan.
After you close on a home loan, you'll need a savingsThey'll save over $900/month. That's $10,800 a year
cushion. They focus so much on the mortgage rate,they have in their checking accounts. Not theoretical
that they'll empty all their savings to buy a home. Not amoney. Not the What Would Dave Ramsey Do
good idea! Tell me, does it matter if you get the lowest(WWDR) approach of "cancel your cable and take
rates in Texas if you don't have $500 left to yourthe difference and put it into a municipal bond so you
name after closing?can make 1.3% over 10 years" But real money.
This is one reason why people should consider 95%Financial planning truly begins on the mortgage level.
loans. There's a myth out there that most people withHome Equity Loans: If you are going to refinance, at
good credit put 20% down--but most the 80-90-95%least look at something larger than the mortgage rate.
home loan clients are PhDs, teachers, physicians,For example, let's say you're current mortgage is 7%
engineers, Aggies, OU Sooners, who could easily putand rates are at 5.75%. You'd really like to refinance
5-10% down. They choose to keep mortgage downand lower your bills. Let's say, if you took advantage of
payments to a minimum so they can put more moneythe 5.75% you'd save $100/month. Hey-that's progress!
elsewhere, like money markets, buying investmentBut what if you took some equity out of your home
homes, etc.and paid most/all of your non-tax deductible debt off in
Refinance Rule #3) Pay of home before 30 yearsthe process? This probably would save you
and save a ton in interest.....you shouldn't pay for your$500-$700 month. Then you could take some of the
house 3 times.savings and apply it to your principal and pay a 30
Go with the loan that moves you forward financially. Ifyear mortgage off in 15-20 years. That is a very
this is a 15 year refinance-great. But if you have debtimportant step-and here is where I agree with Dave
and you're paying lots of money out each month-yourRamsey-you must have a budget because without
best bet is going with a home equity loan. The fewerthis you'll get back into debt.
bills you have the better.Refinancing to get a low rate is good. The second
Mortgage rates go up and go down...so chasing aapproach moves you to an entirely different financial
magical rate is kinda stressful. And waiting for thesituation.
market to come your way takes you out of control ofI mean, you're going to have closing costs anyway.
your finances. I mean, if rates are 7% and you'reWhy not go with a home loan that will move you
waiting on rates in the 4% range, you may be waitingforward financially vs. one that will just save you $100.
a few years.Some people think home equity loans are not good.
Have a strategy when going into the home loan orGurus like Dave Ramsey don't encourage them. But if
refinance- and "use" the mortgage to execute yourthe numbers make sense-who's to argue? Is Dave
game plan. Mortgages are just tools. And choosing theRamsey going to pay your bills for you?
right tool is very important.Dave teaches some great time-tested fundamental
Ask yourself: "Is there a better way to approach aprinciples. Most of which I agree with. Budgeting, saving,
home loan or refinance than just trying to get somelow debt...but the more I listen to his show the more I
"magical low rate." Naturally, rate is important, closingsee his main goal is this: " Get to zero."
costs are too, but let's try to blend two objectives. The"Don't owe anyone anything"...which is good. He even
more things you can accomplish with your refinancethrows some Bible verses around. Who could disagree
the better you will be and the better ROI you get fromwith a simplistic message of getting to zero?
your closing costs.I don't think you win the financial game by getting to
For most people, they only aim at the mortgage rate.zero. I believe you get there when you have money.
So what do mortgage companies do...they give lowWhen you have assets. And anyone who takes a
rates to these people. But With PMI...black and white approach to anything, I tend to
PMI: Consider this, if your rate is 6.00% and the housedisagree with. Few things in life are 100%-and money is
payment is $1000. But your PMI is $200 month do youno different. If you called Dave's show and said "Hey I
still think your rate is 6% if you're paying $1200/month?make good money but I my retirement is iffy at best. I
Why don't more people avoid PMI-it's almost always aonly have 30K in retirement and I'm 50 years old." He's
waste of money. You guessed it. Home loans that arelikely to suggest you need to budget more, maybe cut
80/20 or 80/10 or 80/15s have higher rates becauseout some vacations and buy another book of his.
these are riskier than single loans.If you called, me and you'd didn't have any goals of
And did you know mortgage people make moreyour own-I'd probably suggest the things that Dave
money on single loans vs. 80/20s or 80/15/5 loans?suggest- but I'd encourage you to buy investment
Or take 95% home loans...these rates are higher thanproperties or some other growth vehicle. If your IRA is
20% down. But sometimes people want to keep theirgrowing at 1-2% and we find some properties that are
money vs putting it towards a home. Maybe they aregrowing at 3-5-7% I'd might even encourage you to
self-employed and can get a greater return on thisput more of your savings towards a higher yield
money elsewhere or maybe they can take the 5%vehicle like established real estate. No specs stuff.
down and eliminate all their consumer debt. EachThen, with the right planning and discipline, you could
person is different and has different goals andretire with several properties that have equity.
incomes.Then, with these assets you could sell them or keep
So how do we actually blend these goals of low ratesthem and enjoy passive income during your retirement
with financial planning? What do the "Refinance rules"years. Whichever approach you take-you'll need to get
look like in real life.some points on the board because "getting to zero" is
Someone calls and says "I want to lower my rate. Ino long term game plan. Most people need to take the
want to lower monthly bills." Okay, great. That's prettyDave Ramsey PLUS perspective.... Take the
general. Sorta like most high school boys want a nicebudgeting, savings, getting out of debt time-tested
car and a pretty girlfriend. Who doesn't want this?fundamentals--PLUS buying and keeping assets and
But what if we took at bigger approach to things andstarting businesses, even if you have to incur debt.
blended your goals for a refinance rule and addedBecause getting to zero should not be the goal and
"eliminate consumer debt" to the equation. What loanevery mortgage should have a specific purpose to
would we choose if the objective was to reduce yourmove you forward financially.
family's overall monthly expenses-not just the